Deere & Co. Reaches $99 Million Settlement in Multiyear “Right-to-Repair” Litigation

While the company emphasizes a commitment to customer service and innovation, repair advocates suggest pending state legislation might offer stronger protections for farmers.

Deere & Co. recently announced a settlement agreement resolving the “right-to-repair” litigation before the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois. The company will pay $99 million (plus interest accruing since January 15, 2026) into a settlement fund for the benefit of the settlement class. In a press release, the company states the agreement brings the case to a close with “no finding of wrongdoing.”

The agreement marks a pivotal moment in the multi-year legal battle, aiming to compensate producers for repair restrictions while avoiding a formal admission of liability. While Deere marks the move as a step toward better customer support, the settlement fuels a debate with advocates who argue the payout fails to address control over farm machinery repairs.

Under the terms of the settlement, Deere will establish a fund to cover administrative and legal fees, with the remainder distributed to eligible class members. Deere says it remains committed to supporting customers with access to manuals, diagnostic software, and specialized tools.

“As we continue to innovate industry-leading equipment and technology solutions supported by our world-class dealer network, we are equally committed to providing customers and other service providers with access to repair resources,” says Denver Caldwell, Vice President, Aftermarket & Customer Support. “We’re pleased that this resolution allows us to move forward and remain focused on what matters most – serving our customers.”

Industry Advocates Raise Questions Amid Settlement Announcement

Despite the settlement, some are still skeptical.

“I suspect there is a lot less to this deal than meets the eye,” says Gay Gordon-Byrne, Executive Director of the Repair Association.

She has questions, including that in the settlement Deere agreed to make available to farmers for 10 years “the digital tools required for the maintenance, diagnosis and repair” of large agricultural equipment, including tractors, combines and sugarcane harvesters. What does that mean for other John Deere equipment?

In response, John Deere says its latest digital self-repair tool, Operations Center PRO Service, launched in July 2025, is designed to enhance how John Deere equipment owners use, maintain, diagnose, repair, and protect their equipment. The tool provides support capabilities across John Deere’s agriculture, turf, construction, and forestry equipment portfolio.

Yet unknown, Gordon-Byrne says, are the outcomes of 16 right-to-repair bills that cover ag equipment filed this year in 16 states. “Several are likely to pass with much stronger requirements,” she adds.

Meanwhile, Willie Cade, Repair Association board member and a consultant on the case since it was filed in 2022, says he believes Deere will continue to move the goalposts and keep farmers reliant on their “monopolistic” repair policy. “It’s too little, too late, and it will not fundamentally change the monopolistic repair environment that Deere enjoys,” he says.

The U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois must still approve the settlement.

EDITOR’S TAKE:

What a tangled web this has been. Will settling the lawsuit clear the air? It’s unlikely. Ongoing skepticism and complaints by those seeking to do their own repairs on very sophisticated and computer driven equipment continues to keep dark clouds positioned just outside the courtroom. The prospect of stricter state legislation would again raise concerns and likely put this issue right back in the courtroom. As always, we will continue to monitor this important issue.

One thing you might consider monitoring is how well your dealership is taking advantage of your CAD membership. How could you do this? We have the answer with our new CAD Performance Measurement Program. It allows you to monitor and track your performance at the macro (dealership) level -- right down to each salesperson or department. It allows you to see the potential market share and then measure against that metric. If you want to see how it would work for you, give our team a call.